Amish Funnel Cakes

Sunday 9 January 2022

Amish Funnel Cakes

 
Ahhh Funnel Cakes.  Funnel Cakes are a regional type of deep fried pancake/donut/sweet food.  Originating  in Pennsylvania they are German Dutch in origin, and a staple at most summer county fairs.

I recently got a new cookbook, The Amish Community Cookbook.  I love Amish anything and so was keen to try one of the recipes from the book. 


Amish Funnel Cakes 

After all of the snow of yesterday, I was feeling rather industrious and so I decided to make the Funnel Cakes. I was not sure how a funnel cake should look, or even how it should taste as I have never had one.


The above couple of photos are ones that I bought on my Shutterstock account.  I thought you should see what they are supposed to look like.



Amish Funnel Cakes 


Try not to laugh too hard. This is what mine turned out like.  And this is the best of them.  


Most of them are way worse than this.  WAAAAY worse!  I tried!  However terrible they looked however they did taste good.  I think making them is an art form.  I didn't get the memo on how to perfect them when it was being handed out. 



Amish Funnel Cakes 


WHAT DO YOU NEED TO MAKE AMISH FUNNEL CAKES

Really simple ingredients actually, which is what attracted me to them. I did cut the recipe down to only 1/4th of the recipe (glad that I did) so those measurements you will see in the brackets at the back of each ingredient.

  • 4 large free range eggs (1)
  • 3 cups (720ml) milk (3/4 cup/180ml)
  • 1/4 cup (50g) sugar (1 TBS)
  • 4 cups (560g) plain all purpose flour (1 cup/140g)
  • 4 tsp baking powder (1 tsp)
  • 2 tsp salt (1/2 tsp)
  • vegetable oil for frying (I used canola)
  • icing sugar to dust



Amish Funnel Cakes 

I think it is really necessary, for continuity, to have an actual funnel to make these cakes. I didn't have one, but thought I could just pour the batter in a thin stream into the hot oil. 

I was wrong.  I must put  a funnel on my shopping list of things to eventually get for my kitchen.  The list keeps growing, although I finally did remember to get toothpicks.



Amish Funnel Cakes 


HOW TO MAKE AMISH FUNNEL CAKES


It should be quite simple, but I discovered as simple as it sounds, it is really quite harder than you think.  At least if you want nice looking ones. I did cut the recipe down to 1/4th of its original size.


Beat the eggs in a bowl. Beat in the milk and the sugar.



Amish Funnel Cakes 


Sift together the flour, baking powder and salt. Add to the egg mixture and beat well together with a wire whisk. Leave to sit for about 10 minutes. Whisk again.

Leaving it sit for that time helps to develop the gluten in the flour and gives you a smoother batter.

Heat some oil (about 1/2 inch) in a large deep skillet to 375*F/190*C. 



Amish Funnel Cakes 

Pour 1/2 cup (120ml) of batter through a funnel into the heated oil. Fry for a couple of minutes on each side. Drain on paper towels. 

Dust with icing sugar before serving. 


Amish Funnel Cakes  


WHAT I FOUND CHALLENGING ABOUT MAKING FUNNEL CAKES

Of course much of this could be simply because I did not have a funnel, but for me the real challenge was having the batter come out uniformly for each cake,  and like long tubes.


The trick was to allow the batter to drizzle into the hot fat and not end up all on one spot like a lump. You want it to look like a tangled mass of yarn or a bundle of worms. (I know not appealing to think about.)


Amish Funnel Cakes 


This is the closest that I came to it and as you can see it ended up as a long coil pretty much. It did look nice but here is where the second thing I found challenging came in.


It is incredibly difficult to turn them over.  I used two forks and a then a fork and a spatula.  I was really leery of burning myself with the hot fat. 



Amish Funnel Cakes 


If there is a way of doing it and I discovered that you need to keep the batter constantly moving as you pour it into the hot oil, kind of zig zagging around in a circle, but crossing over back and forth.


Another thing is if you don't have a frying thermometer, and I don't, you might be a bit flummoxed when it comes to knowing when your oil is hot enough.



Amish Funnel Cakes 

You can either dollop a tiny bit of the batter into the pan/hot oil. If it bubbles immediately you know that your oil is hot enough.


You can also use the end of the handle on a wooden spoon. If you stick that into the oil and the oil bubbles immediately around it, then you know your oil is hot enough.  A toothpick will also work. 



Amish Funnel Cakes 


Mine did turn out quite light and crisp. With a lovely texture. They were cooked throughout, although I did leave a few of them in the oil a bit too long on one side. (That was my fear of flipping them.)


I am not sure however if I would ever attempt to make them again.   Not sure if the fat fry smell is worth it.  I was burning candles afterwards. In the summer I could have just opened a few windows and doors.




Amish Funnel Cakes



They were fun to try however and I do like trying new things.  I am a bit afraid of deep fat however, so that could have tempered my experience a tiny bit, and taken away a bit from the fun of it.


I have never felt truly comfortable frying things in deep fat. Not even when I was at college.  You can so easily be burned.  Full disclosure here.    I think I will leave these to the community fair experts and the Amish in the future, however tasty they may have been. 





Of course, not all of my funnel cakes turned out looking great. They say you have to ruin a few pancakes to get a good one. Haha. 


This is one of the ruined ones. One of the ones which came out looking not-so-good. I had more than a few of those.


Amish Funnel Cakes


Never mind, my loss was the bird's gain. I heard no complaints.  A few of them did look quite nice. The rest?  Well, we won't talk about that.  Sometimes you just have to be able to laugh at yourself eh?



 All of the content you see here on this page, both photography and written, are the sole property of The English Kitchen, Marie Rayner. Any reposting or misuse is not permitted. If you are reading this elsewhere, please know that it is stolen content and you may report it to me at mariealicejoan at aol dot com. 


8 comments

  1. Hi Marie, I've always wondered how funnel cakes were made and now I know. I doubt I would make them as I've always had a fear of frying, and how do you dispose of the oil? How do you present your lesson at church since you can't be there? Zoom? Enjoy a peaceful Sunday. Love and hugs, Elaine

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I can pretty much say that I doubt I would try them again Elaine, but at least I tried them once. I have a large jar that I put used oil in. We do our meetings on Zoom. Right now I am able to watch church in the UK at 6 am, and then we have lessons here at 10:00 am via zoom, no in person meetings at the moment. What a life, eh? Love, hugs and a very peaceful Sunday for you as well! xoxo

      Delete
  2. I would love to make these as I love them at fairs but don't think i'll ever be brave enough!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. The batter is easy to put together, but cooking them is a bit more complicated than one would suppose! xoxo

      Delete
  3. I recently discovered that an open bowl of vinegar takes away the smell of fried food. We had fondue for dinner New Year's Eve and I googled something that would take away the smell. Usually by morning the smell still lingers, but this time, "NONE!" My husband cooked some chicken in the air fryer which left a lingering smell. I opened the container of vinegar and soon the smell was gone. I have kept it in a sour cream container and continue to open it, and it still works!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks very much for that handy hint! I will be sure to try it out the next time I am frying! xo

      Delete
  4. I'll pass on the funnel cakes -- I skip frying (other than pan sauteeing!) But I don't think yours look so bad!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I don't do a lot of deep frying either Jeanie. Its a very rare occasion that I do. I don't like the smell and I try to save deep fried foods for a rare treat out! I wanted to try these though. xoxo

      Delete

Thanks for stopping by. I love to hear from you so do not be shy!


BEFORE LEAVING A COMMENT OR RATING, ASK YOURSELF:
Did you make the recipe as directed? Recipe results are not guaranteed when changes have been made.

Is this comment helpful to other readers? Rude or hateful comments will not be approved. Remember that this website is run by a real person.

Are you here to complain about ads? Please keep in mind that I develop these recipes and provide them to you for free. Advertising helps to defray my cost of doing so, and allows me to continue to post regular fresh content.

Thanks so much for your understanding! I appreciate you!