Cheese, Potato and Onion Pie

Thursday 2 March 2017

 photo DSCN0405_zpskar3n7ti.jpg

Who says that a savoury pie has to have meat in it to be good?  This pie is absolutely fabulous!  I found the recipe for it on Lesley's Kitchen, who got it from Holly Bell on the Great British Bakeoff.   I adapted it to use the cheese which I had here in the house and it was totally delish! A bit fiddly with the making of the pastry, but absolutely worth all of the fiddle!  We were all drooling over it in this house!

 photo DSCN0406_zpsiwkwjyhv.jpg

The pastry is what I would call a "Rough Puff"pastry.   It's very crisp and flaky and rises nicely.  I actually like it a lot more than store bought puff pastry . . .  and it wasn't really hard to do at all.  It went together very easily.  You simply mix together equal parts of lard and butter.  You rub a fourth of it into the flour/salt mixture, add some vinegar and water and then roll  it out into a rectangle.   Then you dot it with another fourth of the butter mixture and fold it like a book into thirds, chill for five minutes and then repeat another two times, leaving it to chill for half an hour the last time.

 photo DSCN0407_zps7nvya1x3.jpg

The end result is delicious and crisp and just really, REALLY nice!  The filling is not that hard either.  There is no bottom pastry, just top.  You simply caramelize some onions, boil some potato slices, and then layer them in a pie dish with a cheese and cream mixture and a mix of grated cheeses.  (SO lots of cheese!

  photo DSCN0409_zpskw0qhzec.jpg

You attach a thin strip of pastry all around the pie dish for the top crust to adhere to, so it seals the pie up nicely . . .  then pop on the crust and seal it all around.  I decorated mine a bit with trimmings as you can see.  I would have been a bit more inventive than just writing the word Pie in trimmings, but I got rather lazy.  Little cut out flowers or hearts would be nice  . . .

 photo DSCN0413_zpsqw5qboxt.jpg

Washed with a bit of egg wash and vented the pie is then popped into the oven for half an hour on high and then a further hour at a lower temperature  . . .  so that the pastry puffs up nice and golden brown and crisp . . .

  photo DSCN0415_zps3ucymg05.jpg

And the insides with all those scrummy caramelized onions, and potatoes . . .  cream and cheese . . .  all meld together in unctuous gloriosity!  (I made that word up.  Don't you like it?)  Altogether this pie is fabulously delicious.

  photo DSCN0417_zpslfgzpage.jpg

This is a once in a blue moon treat that will have your family oohing and aahing all around the table . . .  and please sir-ing for just one more piece.   You won't even miss the meat.  I gurantee, which makes it perfect for meatless Monday and if you use vegetable shortening instead of lard, quite vegetarian friendly.  (I used shortening because my lard was a bit too old and I wasn't sure about using it.It worked out beautifully.)

 photo DSCN0419_zps3pkr0mmd.jpg

*Cheese, Potato and Onion Pie*
Makes 9-inch pie 
Printable Recipe  

This may seem a bit fiddly to make, but the end result is well worth the effort.  It's delicious!  

For the pastry :

75g unsalted butter, room temperature (1/4 cup plus 1 TBS)
75g lard, room temperature (1/4 cup plus 1 TBS)
200g plain flour (1 1/2 cups
 1⁄2 tsp salt
1⁄2 tbsp white wine vinegar
 about 150ml chilled water (5 fluid ounces)

For the filling:
30g of butter (2 TBS)
280g of onions, peeled and thinly sliced (4 medium onions)
1 tsp salt 
2 tbsp caster sugar 
2lb 1oz potatoes, peeled, sliced (abput 1/3 inch thick)
140g crème fraîche (5 ounces)
4 tbsp double cream 
150g  mature cheddar, grated, divided (1 1/4 cup)
50g of Parmesan cheese, grated (1/4 cup)
100g gruyere cheese, grated (3/4 cup Swiss type cheese)
freshly ground black pepper
freshly ground nutmeg
1 free range egg yolk, beaten with 1 tsp water

 photo DSCN0415_zps3ucymg05.jpg

To make the pasty, cream together the butter and the lard.   Divide into four equal portions.  Sift the flour into a bowl with the salt.  Add one fourth of the butter mixture.  Cut it in with a pastry blender or your finger tips until the mixture resembles fine bread crumbs.  Add the white wine vinegar.   Add only enough water to give you a soft dough.  Tip out onto a floured surface.   Pat out into a rectangle that is 1/3 inch thick.   Dot with another fourth of the butter mixture.  Fold the outer thirds of the pastry over the middle third of the pastry like a book.  Cover and put in the fridge for five minutes.   Repeat  two more times.  If any of the butter mixture shows through the pastry scatter over a bit more flour.  Cover and chill for half an hour while you make the filling.

  photo DSCN0418_zps6j8vylz0.jpg

Melt the butter in a large skillet.  Add the onions, salt and sugar.   Cook over medium heat, stirring frequently until the onions have softened and caramelized.   Set aside.
Place the potatoes into a large saucepan of boiling salted water.  Cook for 8 minutes then drain well.
Mix together the creme fraiche and double cream.  Stir in 1 cup of the cheddar cheese and 2 TBS of the Parmesan cheese.   Mix together the remaining cheddar, gruyere and Parmesan cheese in a small bowl.

Take a pie dish and begin layering as follows:  !/4 of the potatoes, 1/3 of the caramelized onions, 1/3 of the gruyere cheese mixture, season with some black pepper and some nutmeg. Pour over half of the cream mixture.    Top with 1/4 of the potatoes, 1/3 of the caramelized onions, 1/3 of the guyere cheese mixture.   Season again with some black pepper and nutmeg.   Repeat using another 1/4 of the potatoes, 1/3 onions, 1/3 guyere cheese.  Top with the remaining cream mixture and then top with the final 1/4 of potatoes, again seasoning.

Preheat the oven to 200*C/400*F/ gas mark 6.  Have ready a baking sheet which you have lined with foil.

Roll the pastry out on lightly floured board, working in one direction only and turning it a quarter turn each time, to a circle larger than the pie dish.  Trim off some of the pastry all the way around.  Brush the edge of the pie dish with some egg wash and adhere the trimmings to it.  Brush the trimmings with some egg wash.   Place the pastry lid on top, pressing down to create a good seal all the way around.   Take a fork and gently press all around the edges.  You can use any off cuts of pastry to decorate the pie as desired.   Brush with the remaining egg wash.  Cut a few steam vents into the top and then place the pie into the heated oven.  Bake for 30 minutes.  Reduce the oven temperature to 180*C/350*F/ gas mark 4.  Bake the pie for one further hour, until golden brown.  If you think the pie is browning too quickly cover lightly with some foil.  Serve hot.

 photo DSCN0406_zpsiwkwjyhv.jpg

This was a tiny bit more fiddly than most of my recipes, but do trust me when I tell you it is well worth any effort taken.   This is repeatable.  Totally.  Bon Appetit!


  1. Oh no Marie! This is making me sooo hungry before I go to sleep! Lol. You are by no means lazy! Hugs and Prayers to you and your Todd! I hope he has a very speedy recovery! Jan

    1. Thanks very much Jan! Much appreciated! You need to try this pie! It's gorgeous! xoxo

  2. That looks so wonderful! How can you go wrong with cheese, onions and potatoes? Yum!

  3. Your crust is perfection..interesting the wine vinegar:) Vinegar..I am sued to:)

  4. Carbs and cheese - a marriage made in heaven. ♥ I shall try this on the weekend.

    1. Not sure why, but I just got your comment Marie! How did you get on with this? I hope it was enjoyed! xo

  5. Wish we could easily find double cream and crème fraîche here in the USA. Products readily available in our grocery stores are no where nearly the quality of those two. I'd have to make my own, and only after finding a farmer or farmers' market willing to sell whole raw milk which is against the law in many states here. The British Bake Off show is one of my favorites. The ingredients available to them is amazing, and their array of kitchen implements is an education to me. So interesting, and they make it look so easy. Husband is diabetic which takes most fun out of cooking, but this potato, onion, cheese pie would be doable. Yours looks delicious!

    1. Thanks Barbee! You could use heavy cream and full fat sour cream in their place. Not quite the same but you would still end up with a very delicious dinner! xo

  6. Well true, and as we've never had the real thing, we probably wouldn't know the difference. It'd be yours and my secret.

  7. Beautiful pie! Bookmarking this to make it later, maybe the weekend. :-)

  8. Marie, after watching the Great British Bake Off, the pastry in this recipe sounds very much like "Puff Pastry" which we (here in the US) can buy already made in the freezer section. Just wondering if it really IS like puff pastry or similar? This pie looks like something both my English hubby and I would devour!! :)

    1. Susan, it is a rough puff, which is close to puff pastry, but a much easier and less time consuming pastry to make from scratch! xo

  9. The pie looks sensational and has all of the ingredients I love so well. I'd love to try it.

    I'm not finding a way to Pin this. Am I missing something?

    Jane x

    1. If you move your mouse over the upper right hand corner of any photo a pin it button shows up Jane! I think you will love this if you love these ingredients! xo


Thanks for stopping by. I love to hear from you so do not be shy!

Did you make the recipe as directed? Recipe results are not guaranteed when changes have been made.

Is this comment helpful to other readers? Rude or hateful comments will not be approved. Remember that this website is run by a real person.

Are you here to complain about ads? Please keep in mind that I develop these recipes and provide them to you for free. Advertising helps to defray my cost of doing so, and allows me to continue to post regular fresh content.

Thanks so much for your understanding! I appreciate you!